1. Topical Cases must provide public health assistance to all of Sub-Saharan Africa
Definitional support:
A. Sub-Saharan Africa means the whole region
Worldweb 05
www.worldwebonline.com/search.pl?w=Sub-Saharan+Africa
Sub Saharan Africa: the region south of the Sahara desert
And
B. To identifies the recipient of something
The New Oxford American Dictionary, 07
To- identifying the recipient or intended recipient of something: he wrote a heart-rending letter to the parents; I am deeply grateful to my parents
2. Violation- the plan only provides assistance to .
3. This is a voting issue for the following:
A. They kill limits by allowing affs that provide assistance to one of 48 countries or any combination of countries. This multiplies the neg research burden by thousands of cases. This kill sindepth education and clash because the neg cannot prepare
B. Kills predictable ground- the resolution says sub-saharan Africa, not the list of countries within SSA. They can use the small size of the aff to shift out of links to DAs
C. They’re only partially topical because they only give assistance to one country. This justifies giving Public health assistance to India because “public health assistance” is part of the resolution
D. T is a prima facia voting issue because the judge only has jurisdiction over the topic
1. Topical Cases must provide public health assistance to all of Sub-Saharan Africa
Definitional support:
A. Sub-Saharan Africa means the whole region
Worldweb 05
www.worldwebonline.com/search.pl?w=Sub-Saharan+Africa
Sub Saharan Africa: the region south of the Sahara desert
And
B. To identifies the recipient of something
The New Oxford American Dictionary, 07
To- identifying the recipient or intended recipient of something: he wrote a heart-rending letter to the parents; I am deeply grateful to my parents
2. Violation- the plan only provides assistance to .
3. This is a voting issue for the following:
A. They kill limits by allowing affs that provide assistance to one of 48 countries or any combination of countries. This multiplies the neg research burden by thousands of cases. This kill sindepth education and clash because the neg cannot prepare
B. Kills predictable ground- the resolution says sub-saharan Africa, not the list of countries within SSA. They can use the small size of the aff to shift out of links to DAs
C. They’re only partially topical because they only give assistance to one country. This justifies giving Public health assistance to India because “public health assistance” is part of the resolution
D. T is a prima facia voting issue because the judge only has jurisdiction over the topic